The David Edge Prize Committee received 29 articles for this year’s prize. The prize is awarded to Taylor M. Moore for the article "An (Un)Natural History: Tracing the Magical Rhinoceros Horn in Egypt" in Isis: The Journal of the History of Science Society (2023).
Bringing together a wide range of literatures, Taylor M. Moore offers a fascinating reading of the ethnographic artefact of the rhinoceros horn amulet, which functions as a window onto yet unwritten social histories of the Trans-Saharan slave trade and the healing and divining work of Sudanese wise women--all set against the backdrop of Egypt’s imperial pursuits in East Africa. The rhinoceros horn is one of the magico-medical objects collected by the British anthropologist Winifred Blackman during her fieldwork in Egypt in the late 1920s and held at the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford. The article traces the rhinoceros horn back to the site of its collection in Egypt to reveal non-Western histories of science/magic/medicine, gender, race, and enslavement. Moore uses STS methodologies to read this object in a new way that illuminates the "networks, actors, and economies whose bodies and labour are generally rendered invisible in Eurocentric histories of global science." She draws on an eclectic blend of archival material from Egypt, Turkey, and the UK to uncover the untold histories of marginalised actors such as Egyptian peasants and Sudanese wise women as producers of scientific knowledge. The fact that the paper can make these connections, speaks to Moore's masterful "reading against the grain" of existing historical documents to centre the experiences of the enslaved and formerly enslaved in Egypt. The jury was impressed by this very ambitious piece and would like to commend Moore for her analytic engagement with an impressive breadth of scholarly and archival sources to tell new stories about secret histories.
The honorable mention was awarded to Daniel Greene for the paper "Landlords of the Internet: Big Data and Big Real Estate" in Social Studies of Science (2022).
The Committee recognises Greene’s paper for its impactful, rigorous and fascinating analysis of the history, business models and power relations underlying the materiality of the internet and the landlords that claim ownership over it.
The 2024 David Edge Prize committee:
Lucy van de Wiel, Chair
Zhaopeng Li
Jaimie Morse
Emily Wanderer
